I had no idea Evelyn Waugh's Brideshead Revisited was a religious novel when I picked it up. In fact, I had no idea it was a religious novel until about 50 pages from the end of the book.
When I last met Evelyn Waugh, I was reading A Handful of Dust, a novel in which religion played no part. I was expecting Brideshead Revisited, then, to be something similar, a sort of comedy of the lives of the wealthy in the British countryside. The characters would be similar to real people, but they would be exaggerated to comic effect.
While the characters did indeed make me laugh with their behavior, they were remarkably well developed in Brideshead Revisited. Waugh strove for something much more realistic, and he of course did a wonderful job. Yes, both novels are set in British estates, and both novels deal with the ways of the upper classes, but the content beyond that is starkly different, and I much prefer Waugh's efforts in his later work. The world is so colorfully created, and the characters are delicious in how they act and react to each other.
The big similarity between the novels is their structure. I was in shock for the entire final third of A Handful of Dust as Last wandered through the jungles and died a horrible death. Up to that point, I had thought the novel was about one thing only to discover that it was about something else entirely. I had the same experience in reading Brideshead Revisited. Up until the final section, I thought Waugh was saying something about families and relationships, the way things rise and fall, and how we shape each other. While I was aware that the Catholic belief of the Flytes was important to the novel, I thought it was a device to separate the Flytes from other families, and a tool for talking about the way that religion can pull people apart instead of giving them peace. Then I read the final section and discovered that Catholicism is at the heart of the novel, and that it is held to be something winning. And Sebastian, who was the center of the first half of the novel, becomes little more than a footnote. We hear of him, but never encounter him again. Waugh is very talented at playing with and thwarting my expectations, and possibly yours too.
In the end, we have a novel in which three men have profound encounters with religion and find God when they need him most. Sebastian, bereft of everything, and scraping along the rough bottom of existence, finds God through Kurt, his German friend who allows Sebastian to fulfill a service to someone else, to live beyond himself. Lord Marchmain, a man who never cared for Catholicism, crosses himself on his deathbed, and finds God when he is on the precipice of death. And Charles Ryder, our narrator, goes through the whole novel a non-believer. When he opens the novel he has lost his last love as he realizes that he and the Army have grown apart like estranged spouses. Then in flashback, we see him lose everything else, from Sebastian to Julia. He finds prayer in Marchmain's death scene as he thinks of Julia; he prays for a sign for her sake, to comfort her. And ironically, in answering his prayer, the good Lord separates Julia and Charles forever. Then as the epilogue closes, Ryder stands a shell of a man. He has lost all human love and now all love for the army. It is no coincidence that Ryder is a painter of architecture. He embraces the things created by man, not by God. Even when he visits South America, he paints not the landscape, but the fallen buildings there. Even Anthony Blanche sees his paintings are essentially the same thing. So there Ryder stands at the end of the novel, thinking about the man-made thing that has meant the most to him in his life, Brideshead. He contemplates that the builders had no idea the live their creation would lead. And that brings him to the chapel and the light that burns therein, for there is another creator who knows exactly where his creations go. And the upnote that Waugh ends on is Ryder finding peace in this discovery. Ryder has found God.
There are of course plenty of other characters who would be worth analyzing, but restrictions of time and space in this short blog prevent me from diving into. The minor character that intrigues me most is Nanny Hawkins, the childhood Nanny who dwells in the attic space of Brideshead. Throughout the 20 years that the novel covers, Nanny is forever in her attic window, simultaneously in touch with all the goings on and way out of touch with what's happening below her. She has a view of all, but her eyes are weak. I wonder if she is not some version of God in this novel. And I wonder what it would mean in she were. I don't know if Waugh had a difficult relationship with God. I learned through Wikipedia that he, like fellow countryman Graham Greene (whose The Power and The Glory also deals with Catholicism and the difficulty of believing), Waugh converted to Catholicism as an adult and embraced it fully. So are we supposed to be critical of Ryder's and Sebastian's profligacy of youth? Are we supposed to feel for Lady Marchmain, who is the whipping-girl for all those who have trouble with God? And how odd is it that Lady Marchmain's death comes and goes without fanfare while Lord Marchmain gets and whole section devoted to his dying? If Nanny is like God, then is her fellow counterpart Ryder's father, whom Ryder notes is like Nanny in that they are the only two people who never change. How problematic is Father Ryder as an analogy for God?
A talented writer can take what a more common writer might turn into a tract and turn it into something grand and beautiful. Graham Greene and Evelyn Waugh have taken a subject that threatens to be made into a sermon and make art out of it, just as Orwell can take a political tract and make a living, breathing story. This was another gem to be discovered thanks to this reading list. Something tells me that Waugh and I would have nothing to talk about if ever we met, and from what I have read about him, I don't even think we would get along. So how talented must he be to create a world and characters, and breathe life into those very things, and weave a story out of them that pulls me in completely when my world view is so different from his? That is the power of literature and art. That is why we read.
Wednesday, March 7, 2012
Sunday, February 26, 2012
We Are All Berliners
The 31st book on our list is Christopher Isherwoods The Berlin Stories. The book was placed at number 31 because it was published in 1946; however, The Berlin Stories is made up of two books: The Last of Mr. Norris, published in 1935, and Goodbye to Berlin, published in 1939. Both books take place in Berlin in the first few years of the 1930s, during which time there was a power struggle in Germany between communists and fascists, and the end of which resulted in Hitler's rise to power. This political backdrop makes for a fascinating stage on which Isherwood tells his stories.
The Berlin Stories is probably most famous today as the source for the Bob Fosse film Cabaret and Liza Minelli's portrayal of Sally Bowles. I have not had the good fortune to see the film, but I did have the pleasure of looking at reviews of it. Even better still, I saw comparative reviews of it and the 1955 adaptation of The Berlin Stories called I am a Camera. Presumably the reviewers had not read Isherwood's book because they spoke of Julie Harris's Sally Bowles as not being energetic enough and Laurence Harvey's Isherwood of not being gay enough.
But the Isherwood of The Berlin Stories (known as William Bradshaw in The Last of Mr. Norris) is not openly gay. His desires and cravings do not enter into the stories at all. He is a narrator that provides actions and reactions to the characters he meets, because in spite of the political backdrop, the novel is first and foremost a character study. And Isherwood's sense of character is what makes the book so enjoyable.
From Mr. Norris to Frl. Shroeder to Otto, Herr Schmidt, the Baron, Sally Bowles, to the most minor or characters, Isherwood brings them all to life. And who they are comes to us through their interactions with the narrator, who while remaining constant himself, means something different to each of them. Isherwood makes this relationship clear by having each character call him something different. To Frl. Schroeder, he is Herr Issyvoo, to Fritz and Sally he is Chris, to Otto and his family, he is Christoph, etc. I love the way Isherwood allows his narrator to have a life of his own and simultaneously allow other characters to pour themselves into him. There is a genuine love that Isherwood feels for all the characters he invents (or recreates from the real people he encountered in his time in Germany), and that love makes them all vibrant, fragile, lovable, and as close to alive as paper people become.
Much has been said already about who Isherwood creates, namely those people living on the fringes of society: the poor, prostitutes, con artists, bartenders, gay men and woman. This choice of characters no doubt reflects his own tendernesses, but it also aligns with the political environment in which he sets his novel. The main power struggle in both novels that make up The Berlin Stories takes place between the Nazis and the Communists. This conflict is more apparent in The Last of Mr. Norris, in which Norris and the narrator both join the Communist group for their own reasons. The leader of the Communists, Ludwig, is an incredibly charming man who seems to always be smiling and always know more than anyone else in the room. We learn near the end of his story, that he knew Mr. Norris was selling information about the Communist party, but he doesn't care about the betrayal. To him, the Communist party has room for everyone, even traitors. I kept waiting for something ugly to be revealed about Ludwig, but nothing ever was. Ludwig, and the communist party in turn, were the opposite of the Nazi's in Isherwood's novel. The Nazis are clearing house, attacking everyone who is not like them, while the Communists have open arms, and no matter who you are you have a place and a purpose; not matter who you are, you are welcome.
By 1939, when Isherwood published Goodbye to Berlin, the extent of the Nazi's hatred had revealed itself and the problems with Communism were also more apparent, so the second story is even darker in its political portrait. This political setting is, I think, what allows this collection of character stories to be so successful. There is not much of a plot in each of the stories, but there is a consistent and solid world that ties them all together, and the political happenings help give each story its own movement. Even though I never knew where a story was heading, I always felt like it was going somewhere, and the ride was always a good one because the world and the characters were so captivating.
This is not a roller-coaster of a ride kind of novel. This is not what they call a page-turner. But it is a novel that moves, that has a pace, and that provides a wonderful experience to the reader. If you are a reader who prizes character over action (but one who still demands a story in which those can exist) then you should plunge right into The Berlin Stories!
The Berlin Stories is probably most famous today as the source for the Bob Fosse film Cabaret and Liza Minelli's portrayal of Sally Bowles. I have not had the good fortune to see the film, but I did have the pleasure of looking at reviews of it. Even better still, I saw comparative reviews of it and the 1955 adaptation of The Berlin Stories called I am a Camera. Presumably the reviewers had not read Isherwood's book because they spoke of Julie Harris's Sally Bowles as not being energetic enough and Laurence Harvey's Isherwood of not being gay enough.
But the Isherwood of The Berlin Stories (known as William Bradshaw in The Last of Mr. Norris) is not openly gay. His desires and cravings do not enter into the stories at all. He is a narrator that provides actions and reactions to the characters he meets, because in spite of the political backdrop, the novel is first and foremost a character study. And Isherwood's sense of character is what makes the book so enjoyable.
From Mr. Norris to Frl. Shroeder to Otto, Herr Schmidt, the Baron, Sally Bowles, to the most minor or characters, Isherwood brings them all to life. And who they are comes to us through their interactions with the narrator, who while remaining constant himself, means something different to each of them. Isherwood makes this relationship clear by having each character call him something different. To Frl. Schroeder, he is Herr Issyvoo, to Fritz and Sally he is Chris, to Otto and his family, he is Christoph, etc. I love the way Isherwood allows his narrator to have a life of his own and simultaneously allow other characters to pour themselves into him. There is a genuine love that Isherwood feels for all the characters he invents (or recreates from the real people he encountered in his time in Germany), and that love makes them all vibrant, fragile, lovable, and as close to alive as paper people become.
Much has been said already about who Isherwood creates, namely those people living on the fringes of society: the poor, prostitutes, con artists, bartenders, gay men and woman. This choice of characters no doubt reflects his own tendernesses, but it also aligns with the political environment in which he sets his novel. The main power struggle in both novels that make up The Berlin Stories takes place between the Nazis and the Communists. This conflict is more apparent in The Last of Mr. Norris, in which Norris and the narrator both join the Communist group for their own reasons. The leader of the Communists, Ludwig, is an incredibly charming man who seems to always be smiling and always know more than anyone else in the room. We learn near the end of his story, that he knew Mr. Norris was selling information about the Communist party, but he doesn't care about the betrayal. To him, the Communist party has room for everyone, even traitors. I kept waiting for something ugly to be revealed about Ludwig, but nothing ever was. Ludwig, and the communist party in turn, were the opposite of the Nazi's in Isherwood's novel. The Nazis are clearing house, attacking everyone who is not like them, while the Communists have open arms, and no matter who you are you have a place and a purpose; not matter who you are, you are welcome.
By 1939, when Isherwood published Goodbye to Berlin, the extent of the Nazi's hatred had revealed itself and the problems with Communism were also more apparent, so the second story is even darker in its political portrait. This political setting is, I think, what allows this collection of character stories to be so successful. There is not much of a plot in each of the stories, but there is a consistent and solid world that ties them all together, and the political happenings help give each story its own movement. Even though I never knew where a story was heading, I always felt like it was going somewhere, and the ride was always a good one because the world and the characters were so captivating.
This is not a roller-coaster of a ride kind of novel. This is not what they call a page-turner. But it is a novel that moves, that has a pace, and that provides a wonderful experience to the reader. If you are a reader who prizes character over action (but one who still demands a story in which those can exist) then you should plunge right into The Berlin Stories!
Friday, February 3, 2012
A Book More Equal than Other Books
How many overtly political novels can you think of that are embraced and praised by people of every political persuasion? Conservatives, liberals, capitalists, socialists, and even communists? George Orwell's Animal Farm is amazing because everyone loves it, and everyone loves it because it is amazing.
I can't imagine that I have anything new to say about this book or that anyone needs a review of it, so I will be brief. To me, the book is embraced by all because it breaks down so completely and so simply the means of manipulation that one group uses to control another. Before the invention of the photograph, how horses physically ran was a mystery. Their feet flew too fast to see, and it was popular to debate in the second half of the 19th century whether all four hooves of a horse were ever off the ground at the same time. It wasn't until Eadweard Muybridge took photos and put together a display that the case was settled. George Orwell does something similar with power and manipulation. And we can all appreciate the analysis and see it at work around us even today, no matter who is the force attempting to manipulate.
Squealer is the perfect media machine, creating numbers to "prove" what is not true, rewriting history freely and faulting the animals' bad memories and pernicious lies for the misunderstanding, and gleefully justifying why the ruling class needs special treatment "or else Jones will return." We see this combination of "facts," historical revision, and threats coming from all sides in order to gain our consent for a system that is not in our interest. Similarly, the animals don't have the wherewithal to argue against the lies, and even when they do, the distractions of the bleating sheep destroy that moment of potential protest. Our collective amnesia about the past is a common complaint today, and we see evidence of the "distractions" that pull our mind from the thing we should be focusing on. The right complains of the left employing these tactics, and the left complains of the right, and we all feel like the "lower animals" suffering in a system that is geared entirely against us.
Orwell, a literary hero of mine, manages to combine a direct and powerful writing style with a comprehensive political understanding and brings it all together with an unerring sense of story. At no point does his novel become a political tract. It is always a story first, and an incredible story at that. Stalin and Trotsky are just names in history books today, but Napoleon and Snowball will live forever.
I can't imagine that I have anything new to say about this book or that anyone needs a review of it, so I will be brief. To me, the book is embraced by all because it breaks down so completely and so simply the means of manipulation that one group uses to control another. Before the invention of the photograph, how horses physically ran was a mystery. Their feet flew too fast to see, and it was popular to debate in the second half of the 19th century whether all four hooves of a horse were ever off the ground at the same time. It wasn't until Eadweard Muybridge took photos and put together a display that the case was settled. George Orwell does something similar with power and manipulation. And we can all appreciate the analysis and see it at work around us even today, no matter who is the force attempting to manipulate.
Squealer is the perfect media machine, creating numbers to "prove" what is not true, rewriting history freely and faulting the animals' bad memories and pernicious lies for the misunderstanding, and gleefully justifying why the ruling class needs special treatment "or else Jones will return." We see this combination of "facts," historical revision, and threats coming from all sides in order to gain our consent for a system that is not in our interest. Similarly, the animals don't have the wherewithal to argue against the lies, and even when they do, the distractions of the bleating sheep destroy that moment of potential protest. Our collective amnesia about the past is a common complaint today, and we see evidence of the "distractions" that pull our mind from the thing we should be focusing on. The right complains of the left employing these tactics, and the left complains of the right, and we all feel like the "lower animals" suffering in a system that is geared entirely against us.
Orwell, a literary hero of mine, manages to combine a direct and powerful writing style with a comprehensive political understanding and brings it all together with an unerring sense of story. At no point does his novel become a political tract. It is always a story first, and an incredible story at that. Stalin and Trotsky are just names in history books today, but Napoleon and Snowball will live forever.
Tuesday, January 31, 2012
All the King's Men
This blog was originally intended for those reading along with the list that kicked this journey off. According to this original vision, my entries would be one of many and a conversation would arise between blogs as our different impressions and interpretations came together. To that end, I was only too happy to include spoilers in my entries so that we could discuss the books in as much specific detail as possible.
It now seems that I am the last man standing, as it were, and the few who read my posts read them as a kind of book review. Because of this change, I will be spoiling as little as possible in my following posts. If anyone out there wants to discuss things in detail, please make comments, get down to business, and I will meet you there!
Robert Penn Warren is an amazing writer. I had seen the black and white film version of All the King's Men, but I had never read the book before. It is of course common place to note that a book is better than its cinematic counterpart, but I don't always feel that that is true. If a book is heavily plot-driven, it can typically be made into a successful film because cinema loves action and doing; it can show that vividly and powerfully. My impression of All the King's Men from the movie is that the book is about Willie Stark, the country bumpkin who rises to power as the Governor of an unnamed state, and who then confuses his ambitions for power and for doing good. It is a story of the rise and fall of one man and all the collateral damage that creates. Indeed, even reading the jacket cover of my edition, that is the story that it summarizes.
I was surprised then to find almost halfway into the book that the narrator is not simply Watson to Stark's Holmes, but that he is the very center of the novel. The richness of this story is the richness of the narrator's observations and feelings. The extent to which this is an amazing book, and it is indeed an amazing book, has everything to do with Jack Burden's self-loving, self-loathing, caring, uncaring relationship with himself and the world he operates in. Robert Penn Warren brings everything he has to this book and touches upon so many aspects of humanity that I have no idea how he found anything else to write about in the 40 years of his life that followed the publication of this book.
Jack Burden is straight out of a hard-boiled detective novel. He is world-weary and wise and shocked by nothing. He talks the tough talk and doesn't get emotionally attached. And he watches everything and everyone to see which way things go. The difference is that Jack isn't out to make a buck or save someone's life. Moreover, he has failed relationships with everyone in his life, including himself. And the novel reveals those relationships and Jack's every impulse in amazing detail while never once feeling like the pace of the novel is sagging. Hell, the greater portion of one chapter (and the chapters in the book are rather long) is given over to retelling the story of the life, love, and trials of a distant relative during the civil war who was the subject of Jack's dissertation when he was a graduate student of history. It has nothing to do with Willie Stark and yet everything to do with the concerns of the novel and the relationships that boil at its center.
This novel is about good and bad and the good bad people can do and the bad good people can do. It's about the utter uselessness of concepts of good and bad when applied to people. The novel manages to do what so many other storytellers have tried and failed: it presents individuals and society in all its complexity. When others attempt such a thing, you are often presented with a big blob of a mess, everything entangled and meshed, muddy and shadowed. Robert Penn Warren deftly shows the sides of people without destroying the individual impressions, like light shining on a multifaceted gem, the gleam bouncing off one facet sharply without denying the presence of the other facets. In fact, the mere presence of that facet speaks of all the other facets that share a side with it. It is an amazing thing to see.
It now seems that I am the last man standing, as it were, and the few who read my posts read them as a kind of book review. Because of this change, I will be spoiling as little as possible in my following posts. If anyone out there wants to discuss things in detail, please make comments, get down to business, and I will meet you there!
Robert Penn Warren is an amazing writer. I had seen the black and white film version of All the King's Men, but I had never read the book before. It is of course common place to note that a book is better than its cinematic counterpart, but I don't always feel that that is true. If a book is heavily plot-driven, it can typically be made into a successful film because cinema loves action and doing; it can show that vividly and powerfully. My impression of All the King's Men from the movie is that the book is about Willie Stark, the country bumpkin who rises to power as the Governor of an unnamed state, and who then confuses his ambitions for power and for doing good. It is a story of the rise and fall of one man and all the collateral damage that creates. Indeed, even reading the jacket cover of my edition, that is the story that it summarizes.
I was surprised then to find almost halfway into the book that the narrator is not simply Watson to Stark's Holmes, but that he is the very center of the novel. The richness of this story is the richness of the narrator's observations and feelings. The extent to which this is an amazing book, and it is indeed an amazing book, has everything to do with Jack Burden's self-loving, self-loathing, caring, uncaring relationship with himself and the world he operates in. Robert Penn Warren brings everything he has to this book and touches upon so many aspects of humanity that I have no idea how he found anything else to write about in the 40 years of his life that followed the publication of this book.
Jack Burden is straight out of a hard-boiled detective novel. He is world-weary and wise and shocked by nothing. He talks the tough talk and doesn't get emotionally attached. And he watches everything and everyone to see which way things go. The difference is that Jack isn't out to make a buck or save someone's life. Moreover, he has failed relationships with everyone in his life, including himself. And the novel reveals those relationships and Jack's every impulse in amazing detail while never once feeling like the pace of the novel is sagging. Hell, the greater portion of one chapter (and the chapters in the book are rather long) is given over to retelling the story of the life, love, and trials of a distant relative during the civil war who was the subject of Jack's dissertation when he was a graduate student of history. It has nothing to do with Willie Stark and yet everything to do with the concerns of the novel and the relationships that boil at its center.
This novel is about good and bad and the good bad people can do and the bad good people can do. It's about the utter uselessness of concepts of good and bad when applied to people. The novel manages to do what so many other storytellers have tried and failed: it presents individuals and society in all its complexity. When others attempt such a thing, you are often presented with a big blob of a mess, everything entangled and meshed, muddy and shadowed. Robert Penn Warren deftly shows the sides of people without destroying the individual impressions, like light shining on a multifaceted gem, the gleam bouncing off one facet sharply without denying the presence of the other facets. In fact, the mere presence of that facet speaks of all the other facets that share a side with it. It is an amazing thing to see.
Tuesday, December 20, 2011
Not Loving Loving
A lot of novels begin in media res, and I have gotten quite comfortable with being confused for a number of pages, if not a number of chapters. When the confusion lasts longer than I would like, I sometimes read the forward or introduction if my edition comes with one. My edition of Henry Green's Loving comes with an introduction by John Updike, and I availed myself of it after stumbling through the first ten pages of the novel. I recharged my battery after reading that "Green, to me, is so good a writer, such a revealer of what English prose fiction can do in this century, that I can launch myself upon this piece of homage and introduction only by falling into some sort of imitation of that liberatingly ingenuous voice, that voice so full of other voices, its own interpolations amid the matchless dialogue twisted and tremulous with a precision that kept the softness of groping, of sensation, of living." Wow, that sounds good!
But I did not find it to be as exhilarating as Updike. It took me a quarter of the book to figure out who was who, and another quarter to feel comfortable with the cast of characters. Then I spent the last half trying to figure out why I was reading the book at all. The uniqueness of Green's voice was lost on me, but I did find his skill at dialogue most impressive. He had many scene transitions that were sharp and clever. And he had a few descriptions that were striking and poetic. But those moments of admiration were moments, disparate and free-floating, unanchored to any plot or theme that I could follow. Summaries of the novel focus on the division of the masters and their servants and on the characters raiding each others turf as the warring nations in Europe simultaneously war with each other, but to say that that is what this novel is about does not ring true for me. The servants gossiped and spied on each other, but nothing about it felt like it was echoing the fighting happening overseas for the characters.
In the end, it's Raunce's story above all others. He is promoted to Butler, falls in love with Edith, and in the end the two elope. There are some power struggles, but nothing is ever really on the line. There could not be said to be any hills or valleys in the story. It is telling that Green avoids any chapters, because chapters suggest a rhythm that I found the novel lacking. So in the end I feel like I didn't understand the novel at all. And my brief search through the interwebz did not shine any light on it. Here is a novelist admired by many, and a novel that has made it not only on this top-100 list but on several others as well. So I just want to understand why.
One of the things that I like about reading from a top-100 list is that I can assume that what I am reading is good or ground-breaking in its own way. When a book takes an odd turn or does something that I would never expect, I can assume that the author had a reason for doing so, that doing so is part of his or her very point. I don't expect all the novels to be gripping or to be great in every category (character, plot, pacing, writing, etc.), but I do expect each novel to be doing one of two things: Giving me a good yarn or saying something about the world we live in. The good yarn I can do without if the characters and world portrayed are vibrant and absorbing, which they are indeed in this novel. But I can't say that this novel is saying anything about anything.
So there it is. It's not the worst book I've read. It's not the lamest book I've read. It's not the most confusing book I've read. I just don't get it. So if anyone out there can enlighten me, please do!
But I did not find it to be as exhilarating as Updike. It took me a quarter of the book to figure out who was who, and another quarter to feel comfortable with the cast of characters. Then I spent the last half trying to figure out why I was reading the book at all. The uniqueness of Green's voice was lost on me, but I did find his skill at dialogue most impressive. He had many scene transitions that were sharp and clever. And he had a few descriptions that were striking and poetic. But those moments of admiration were moments, disparate and free-floating, unanchored to any plot or theme that I could follow. Summaries of the novel focus on the division of the masters and their servants and on the characters raiding each others turf as the warring nations in Europe simultaneously war with each other, but to say that that is what this novel is about does not ring true for me. The servants gossiped and spied on each other, but nothing about it felt like it was echoing the fighting happening overseas for the characters.
In the end, it's Raunce's story above all others. He is promoted to Butler, falls in love with Edith, and in the end the two elope. There are some power struggles, but nothing is ever really on the line. There could not be said to be any hills or valleys in the story. It is telling that Green avoids any chapters, because chapters suggest a rhythm that I found the novel lacking. So in the end I feel like I didn't understand the novel at all. And my brief search through the interwebz did not shine any light on it. Here is a novelist admired by many, and a novel that has made it not only on this top-100 list but on several others as well. So I just want to understand why.
One of the things that I like about reading from a top-100 list is that I can assume that what I am reading is good or ground-breaking in its own way. When a book takes an odd turn or does something that I would never expect, I can assume that the author had a reason for doing so, that doing so is part of his or her very point. I don't expect all the novels to be gripping or to be great in every category (character, plot, pacing, writing, etc.), but I do expect each novel to be doing one of two things: Giving me a good yarn or saying something about the world we live in. The good yarn I can do without if the characters and world portrayed are vibrant and absorbing, which they are indeed in this novel. But I can't say that this novel is saying anything about anything.
So there it is. It's not the worst book I've read. It's not the lamest book I've read. It's not the most confusing book I've read. I just don't get it. So if anyone out there can enlighten me, please do!
Sunday, November 20, 2011
Lonely Hunters Make Good Company
In spite of my long silence, the search for smarts continues. I took some time to read Watership Down with my son and I have begun reading Dune aloud to Ann. It is one of her favorite books, but it is my first time reading it. In addition, I got lassoed into reading a free market economics book that is draining my soul.
But onward with the subject at hand: Carson McCullers's The Heart Is a Lonely Hunter. We all have certain subject matters and writing styles that resonate with us on what feels like a primordial level, and McCullers and this novel do just that for me. Like Cannery Row and Winesburg, Ohio, The Heart Is a Lonely Hunter takes a look at human suffering at its finest, at the efforts we make to reach out to the world around us, at the inevitable failure of those efforts. Every part of this novel was a joy to me. McCullers's writing is powerful in its straightforwardness and it manages to be wonderfully heartwrenching while steering clear of sentimental goop. Moreover, the writing never falls into self-congratulatory profundity even as it makes beautifully profound observations of human desires and interactions. The characters are vibrant and alive, seeming to exist beyond the borders of the page.
As Biff Brannon observes, the lonely creatures surrounding John Singer are able to cast their own image onto Singer due to his muteness. And as Singer observes, the three lonely hearts that seek him out are all obsessed with something they cannot get a hold of. McCullers makes it clear that Singer holds no special powers himself; in fact, he is equally obsessed with and equally able to write his own desires on Antonapoulos. Everyone is casting about to find a fellow soul that vibrates on the same frequency, and often we mistake our own eternal vibration for the like vibration of another.
All interactions in this novel miss their mark. Biff loves Mick, but she sees his attention as something malicious, her own guilty conscience turning his love into suspicion. Jake Blount and Dr. Copeland are fellow political activists who cannot trust themselves or others, who meet for one night of intense discussion only to fall apart and become more distant than ever. Singer's love for Antonapoulos is painful to watch since we know that that love is doomed from the first chapter. Each character has wonderful insights into those around them but is blind to his own motivations and doings. And it seems the more they stumble, the more lost they become. Mick's entrance into adulthood is of course the prime example of this. After her initiation into sexual adulthood, she withdraws not only from those around her, but from herself. She is no longer allowed into her own interior room. Her response is strikingly similar to Bubber's after shooting Baby in the face. Both have crossed a threshold after which childhood is lost, and with childhood, some understanding of ourselves and our own dreams.
Perhaps it is hope that the lonely heart hunts for, hope for a connection and for a world of possibilities. And when that hope dies, something dies in us. For Singer, that death is total. Without Antonapoulos, he has no reason to go on at all. For those who pinned their hopes on Singer, his death sends them into a spiral as well. Mick's estrangement from herself is complete, and Jake's groundedness is lost. We cannot see beyond ourselves. Worse yet, we cannot see within ourselves. Where does that leave us?
Biff seems to be the pivot point of the novel, insofar as he is left standing in the end. He is the only character rooted in the community. I suppose Copeland is certainly rooted, but his desires for a better world take him out and set him on the fringes, as does his skin. No, Biff is the only one settled and unmoving. He is as disconnected as the rest, but there is something resigned in him that allows him to keep soldiering on even as the world changes. His loneliness doesn't seem as painful, and I can't decide if that is an even sadder fate than that of the others.
I took so long to read this novel not because it was a difficult or slow read, but because I was eager for it not to end. I knew from the start that it was not going to end well, and I was in no rush for everything to unravel and slip away. The writing, the characters, the world--they were all too good to let go.
But onward with the subject at hand: Carson McCullers's The Heart Is a Lonely Hunter. We all have certain subject matters and writing styles that resonate with us on what feels like a primordial level, and McCullers and this novel do just that for me. Like Cannery Row and Winesburg, Ohio, The Heart Is a Lonely Hunter takes a look at human suffering at its finest, at the efforts we make to reach out to the world around us, at the inevitable failure of those efforts. Every part of this novel was a joy to me. McCullers's writing is powerful in its straightforwardness and it manages to be wonderfully heartwrenching while steering clear of sentimental goop. Moreover, the writing never falls into self-congratulatory profundity even as it makes beautifully profound observations of human desires and interactions. The characters are vibrant and alive, seeming to exist beyond the borders of the page.
As Biff Brannon observes, the lonely creatures surrounding John Singer are able to cast their own image onto Singer due to his muteness. And as Singer observes, the three lonely hearts that seek him out are all obsessed with something they cannot get a hold of. McCullers makes it clear that Singer holds no special powers himself; in fact, he is equally obsessed with and equally able to write his own desires on Antonapoulos. Everyone is casting about to find a fellow soul that vibrates on the same frequency, and often we mistake our own eternal vibration for the like vibration of another.
All interactions in this novel miss their mark. Biff loves Mick, but she sees his attention as something malicious, her own guilty conscience turning his love into suspicion. Jake Blount and Dr. Copeland are fellow political activists who cannot trust themselves or others, who meet for one night of intense discussion only to fall apart and become more distant than ever. Singer's love for Antonapoulos is painful to watch since we know that that love is doomed from the first chapter. Each character has wonderful insights into those around them but is blind to his own motivations and doings. And it seems the more they stumble, the more lost they become. Mick's entrance into adulthood is of course the prime example of this. After her initiation into sexual adulthood, she withdraws not only from those around her, but from herself. She is no longer allowed into her own interior room. Her response is strikingly similar to Bubber's after shooting Baby in the face. Both have crossed a threshold after which childhood is lost, and with childhood, some understanding of ourselves and our own dreams.
Perhaps it is hope that the lonely heart hunts for, hope for a connection and for a world of possibilities. And when that hope dies, something dies in us. For Singer, that death is total. Without Antonapoulos, he has no reason to go on at all. For those who pinned their hopes on Singer, his death sends them into a spiral as well. Mick's estrangement from herself is complete, and Jake's groundedness is lost. We cannot see beyond ourselves. Worse yet, we cannot see within ourselves. Where does that leave us?
Biff seems to be the pivot point of the novel, insofar as he is left standing in the end. He is the only character rooted in the community. I suppose Copeland is certainly rooted, but his desires for a better world take him out and set him on the fringes, as does his skin. No, Biff is the only one settled and unmoving. He is as disconnected as the rest, but there is something resigned in him that allows him to keep soldiering on even as the world changes. His loneliness doesn't seem as painful, and I can't decide if that is an even sadder fate than that of the others.
I took so long to read this novel not because it was a difficult or slow read, but because I was eager for it not to end. I knew from the start that it was not going to end well, and I was in no rush for everything to unravel and slip away. The writing, the characters, the world--they were all too good to let go.
Wednesday, September 14, 2011
Native Son Shines On
In Native Son, Bigger Thomas, a young black man, murders a teenage white girl, smothering her in her own bed, shoving her body into the family furnace, and cutting off her head so she can fit. Richard Wright does everything he can to make this experience difficult for his white readers. Mary Dalton, the murdered girl, is a young revolutionary who wants to help bring about a world of racial equality. Her mother and father hire Bigger knowing he's had a troubled past with the purpose of bettering him and his family. In addition, Bigger is something of a thug and a bully. When we meet him earlier, we see him intimidate and fight with his friends, turning fear into violence, masking his insecurities and worries by lashing out and humiliating others.
And in spite of stacking the deck against Bigger, Wright makes us feel for him, makes us understand him.
In 1940, the same year Native Son was published, Wright authored an essay entitled "How 'Bigger' was Born." In it, he talks about his motives for making Native Son difficult to react to emotionally:
"I had written a book of short stories which was published under the title of Uncle Tom's Children. When the reviews of that book began to appear, I realized that I had made an awfully naive mistake. I found that I had written a book which even bankers' daughters could read and weep over and feel good about. I swore to myself that if I ever wrote another book, no one would weep over it; that it would be so hard and deep that they would have to face it without the consolation of tears."
There is still one other passage in "How 'Bigger' was Born" that makes me truly appreciate how difficult it must have been for Wright to write this novel with Bigger at its center:
"I felt a mental censor--product of the fears which a negro feels from living in America--standing over me, draped in white, warning me not to write. This censor's warnings were translated into my own thought processes thus: 'What will white people think if I draw the picture of such a negro boy? Will they not at once say: "See, didn't we tell you all along that niggers are like that? Now, look, one of their own kind has come along and drawn the picture for us!"' I felt that if I drew the picture of Bigger truthfully, there would be many reactionary whites who would try to make of him something I did not intend. And yet, and this was what made it difficult, I knew that I could not write Bigger convincingly if I did not depict him as he was: that is, resentful toward whites, sullen, angry, ignorant, emotionally unstable, depressed and unaccountably elated at times, and unable even, because of his own lack of inner organization which American oppression has fostered in him, to unite with the members of his own race."
Bigger is why this book is so gripping. Don't get me wrong; the plot is incredibly well-crafted. By about page 50, I was thoroughly convinced that the Cohen Brothers needed to turn this book into a movie. While they have never really dealt with black America, I could see them treating the murder and Bigger's attempt to conceal the body with such skill. And the kidnapping idea? And the newspaper men gathered about the furnace? And the detective grilling Bigger in the cellar? So many scenes with such intensity, a single bad decision unfurling into a catastrophe. So, yes, the plot was top notch. But Wright's truly wonderful feat was how fully realized Bigger was, and how we are made to understand his impulses and desires whether we feel like him or not. Wright has done an incredible job.
The book on this reading list that I kept thinking about as I read Native Son was Dreiser's An American Tragedy. Both novels deal with the murder of a woman by a man who attempts to cover it up. In both novels the man is motivated by something uniquely "American" (at least as their authors' understand them). Both authors' took the basic story of the murder from current newspaper headlines. And both novels end with a lengthy trial scene and the state-sanctioned murder of the murderer. Dreiser's Clyde pre-plans his murder in an attempt to climb the social ladder by marrying a rich man's daughter. For Dreiser, this desire for wealth and social success is the thing that American society breeds in us. Wright's Bigger is the titular native son, a product of American Jim Crow culture. For as unpleasant as Bigger's character is, those unpleasantries are created by the restrictions and limitations that surround and press upon Bigger like the humid air of Chicago's Southside in Summer. He murders not by design, but by fear, a sudden impulse to survive. These are the origins of all Bigger's actions. Both authors use the trial to build sympathy for the murderer as the overzealous prosecutors attack them, trying to make their horrible crimes even more horrific. I would not be surprised to learn that Wright had Dreiser's novel rolling around in the back of his head.
Wright uses that last section to lay out the thesis of his book, and that portion of the book has been attacked as the weak link. I can understand that. After the gripping drama of the first two books, the pondering pace of the third section is something of a let down. But it feels like Wright is doing more than giving a defense of Bigger's actions. His lawyer's speech is a small portion of the section. Instead we watch as Bigger's actions are interpreted by the prosecutor and as crimes he didn't commit are laid upon him. And we watch as Bigger tries to find his place to live in this world. When he finally comes to peace in the last few pages, I don't know what to make of his lawyers reaction. Mr. Max seems scared of what Bigger says. Is he scared because Bigger's revelations are scary? Or is he scared for Bigger himself and his knowledge that he is on his way to the electric chair?
This entry is long enough, so I will not delve into the importance of communism in this novel, and while I suspect no one reading this (if anyone reads this) will care to join in, I leave that as an open question: Does communism hold the hope for a world of racial equality in this book? And I would also like to write a whole section on the role the newspapers play in shaping and skewing public opinion. Especially as it transforms the question of rape into a certainty. What role do newspapers play in oppression here?
If you haven't read this book, go out and read it now, even if I just spoiled half the novel's storyline. It is a wonderful read!
And in spite of stacking the deck against Bigger, Wright makes us feel for him, makes us understand him.
In 1940, the same year Native Son was published, Wright authored an essay entitled "How 'Bigger' was Born." In it, he talks about his motives for making Native Son difficult to react to emotionally:
"I had written a book of short stories which was published under the title of Uncle Tom's Children. When the reviews of that book began to appear, I realized that I had made an awfully naive mistake. I found that I had written a book which even bankers' daughters could read and weep over and feel good about. I swore to myself that if I ever wrote another book, no one would weep over it; that it would be so hard and deep that they would have to face it without the consolation of tears."
There is still one other passage in "How 'Bigger' was Born" that makes me truly appreciate how difficult it must have been for Wright to write this novel with Bigger at its center:
"I felt a mental censor--product of the fears which a negro feels from living in America--standing over me, draped in white, warning me not to write. This censor's warnings were translated into my own thought processes thus: 'What will white people think if I draw the picture of such a negro boy? Will they not at once say: "See, didn't we tell you all along that niggers are like that? Now, look, one of their own kind has come along and drawn the picture for us!"' I felt that if I drew the picture of Bigger truthfully, there would be many reactionary whites who would try to make of him something I did not intend. And yet, and this was what made it difficult, I knew that I could not write Bigger convincingly if I did not depict him as he was: that is, resentful toward whites, sullen, angry, ignorant, emotionally unstable, depressed and unaccountably elated at times, and unable even, because of his own lack of inner organization which American oppression has fostered in him, to unite with the members of his own race."
Bigger is why this book is so gripping. Don't get me wrong; the plot is incredibly well-crafted. By about page 50, I was thoroughly convinced that the Cohen Brothers needed to turn this book into a movie. While they have never really dealt with black America, I could see them treating the murder and Bigger's attempt to conceal the body with such skill. And the kidnapping idea? And the newspaper men gathered about the furnace? And the detective grilling Bigger in the cellar? So many scenes with such intensity, a single bad decision unfurling into a catastrophe. So, yes, the plot was top notch. But Wright's truly wonderful feat was how fully realized Bigger was, and how we are made to understand his impulses and desires whether we feel like him or not. Wright has done an incredible job.
The book on this reading list that I kept thinking about as I read Native Son was Dreiser's An American Tragedy. Both novels deal with the murder of a woman by a man who attempts to cover it up. In both novels the man is motivated by something uniquely "American" (at least as their authors' understand them). Both authors' took the basic story of the murder from current newspaper headlines. And both novels end with a lengthy trial scene and the state-sanctioned murder of the murderer. Dreiser's Clyde pre-plans his murder in an attempt to climb the social ladder by marrying a rich man's daughter. For Dreiser, this desire for wealth and social success is the thing that American society breeds in us. Wright's Bigger is the titular native son, a product of American Jim Crow culture. For as unpleasant as Bigger's character is, those unpleasantries are created by the restrictions and limitations that surround and press upon Bigger like the humid air of Chicago's Southside in Summer. He murders not by design, but by fear, a sudden impulse to survive. These are the origins of all Bigger's actions. Both authors use the trial to build sympathy for the murderer as the overzealous prosecutors attack them, trying to make their horrible crimes even more horrific. I would not be surprised to learn that Wright had Dreiser's novel rolling around in the back of his head.
Wright uses that last section to lay out the thesis of his book, and that portion of the book has been attacked as the weak link. I can understand that. After the gripping drama of the first two books, the pondering pace of the third section is something of a let down. But it feels like Wright is doing more than giving a defense of Bigger's actions. His lawyer's speech is a small portion of the section. Instead we watch as Bigger's actions are interpreted by the prosecutor and as crimes he didn't commit are laid upon him. And we watch as Bigger tries to find his place to live in this world. When he finally comes to peace in the last few pages, I don't know what to make of his lawyers reaction. Mr. Max seems scared of what Bigger says. Is he scared because Bigger's revelations are scary? Or is he scared for Bigger himself and his knowledge that he is on his way to the electric chair?
This entry is long enough, so I will not delve into the importance of communism in this novel, and while I suspect no one reading this (if anyone reads this) will care to join in, I leave that as an open question: Does communism hold the hope for a world of racial equality in this book? And I would also like to write a whole section on the role the newspapers play in shaping and skewing public opinion. Especially as it transforms the question of rape into a certainty. What role do newspapers play in oppression here?
If you haven't read this book, go out and read it now, even if I just spoiled half the novel's storyline. It is a wonderful read!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)